The Basement Tapes is a 1975 studio album by Bob Dylan and The Band. The songs featuring Dylan’s vocals were recorded in 1967, eight years before the album’s release, at houses in and around Woodstock, NY, where Dylan and the Band lived. Although most of the Dylan songs had appeared on bootleg records, ‘The Basement Tapes’ marked their first official release.
When Columbia Records prepared the album, eight songs recorded solely by the Band were added to sixteen songs taped by Dylan and the Band. Subsequently, the format of the 1975 album has led critics to question the omission of some of Dylan’s best-known 1967 compositions and the inclusion of material by the Band that was not recorded in Woodstock.
During his world tour of 1965–66, Dylan was backed by a five-member rock group, the Hawks, who would later become famous as the Band. After Dylan was injured in a motorcycle accident in 1966, the Hawks’ members gravitated to the vicinity of Dylan’s home in the Woodstock area to collaborate with him on music and film projects. While Dylan was concealed from the public’s gaze during an extended period of convalescence in 1967, they recorded more than 100 tracks together, comprising original compositions, contemporary covers, and traditional material. Dylan’s new style of writing moved away from the urban sensibility and extended narratives that had characterized his most recent albums, ‘Highway 61 Revisited’ and ‘Blonde On Blonde,’ toward songs that were more intimate and which drew on many styles of traditional American music. While some of the basement songs are humorous, others dwell on nothingness, betrayal, and a quest for salvation. In general, they possess a rootsy quality anticipating the Americana genre. For some critics, the songs, which circulated widely in unofficial form, mounted a major stylistic challenge to rock music in the late sixties.
By the summer of 1966, Bob Dylan was at the peak of both creative and commercial success. ‘Highway 61 Revisited’ had reached number three on the US album chart, and the recently released double-LP ‘Blonde on Blonde’ was widely acclaimed. From the fall of 1965 into the spring 1966, Dylan embarked on an extensive tour across the US, Australia, and Europe backed by the Hawks, a band that had formerly worked with rock and roll musician Ronnie Hawkins. The Hawks comprised four Canadian musicians—Rick Danko, Garth Hudson, Richard Manuel, and Robbie Robertson—and one American, Levon Helm. Dylan’s audiences reacted with hostility to the sound of their folk icon backed by a rock band. Dismayed by the negative reception, Helm quit the Hawks and drifted around the South, at one point working on an oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico. The tour culminated in a famously raucous concert in Manchester, England when an audience member shouted ‘Judas!’ at Dylan for allegedly betraying the cause of politically progressive folk music.
Returning exhausted from the hectic schedule of his world tour, Dylan discovered that his manager, Albert Grossman, had arranged a further 63 concerts across the US that year. However, Dylan crashed his Triumph motorcycle near his home in Woodstock, suffering cracked vertebrae and a mild concussion and the concerts were canceled. Biographer Clinton Heylin wrote in 1990 on the significance of the crash: ‘A quarter of a century on, Dylan’s motorcycle accident is still viewed as the pivot of his career. As a sudden, abrupt moment when his wheel really did explode. The great irony is that 1967—the year after the accident—remains his most prolific year as a songwriter.’ In a 1969 interview with ‘Rolling Stone’ co-founder Jann Wenner, Dylan said, ‘I had a dreadful motorcycle accident which put me away for a while, and I still didn’t sense the importance of that accident till at least a year after that. I realized that it was a real accident. I mean I thought that I was just gonna get up and go back to doing what I was doing before … but I couldn’t do it anymore.’
Dylan was rethinking the direction of his life while recovering from a sense of having been exploited. Nine months after the crash, he told ‘New York Daily News’ reporter Michael Iachetta, ‘Songs are in my head like they always are. And they’re not going to get written down until some things are evened up. Not until some people come forth and make up for some of the things that have happened.’ After discussing the crash with Dylan, biographer Robert Shelton concluded that he ‘was saying there must be another way of life for the pop star, in which he is in control, not they. He had to find ways of working to his own advantage with the recording industry. He had to come to terms with his one-time friend, longtime manager, part-time neighbor, and sometime landlord, Albert Grossman.’
Rick Danko recalled that he, Richard Manuel and Garth Hudson joined Robbie Robertson in West Saugerties, a few miles from Woodstock, in February 1967. The three of them moved into a house on Stoll Road nicknamed Big Pink; Robertson lived nearby with his future wife, Dominique. Danko and Manuel had been invited to Woodstock to collaborate with Dylan on a film he was editing, ‘Eat the Document,’ a rarely seen account of the 1966 world tour. At some point between March and June 1967, Dylan and the four Hawks began a series of informal recording sessions, initially at the so-called Red Room of Dylan’s house, Hi Lo Ha, in the Byrdcliffe area of Woodstock. In June, the recording sessions moved to the basement of Big Pink. Hudson set up a recording unit, using two stereo mixers and a tape recorder borrowed from Grossman, as well as a set of microphones on loan from folk trio Peter, Paul, and Mary. Dylan would later tell Jann Wenner, ‘That’s really the way to do a recording—in a peaceful, relaxed setting—in somebody’s basement. With the windows open … and a dog lying on the floor.’
For the first couple of months, they were merely ‘killing time,’ according to Robertson, with many early sessions devoted to covers. ‘With the covers Bob was educating us a little,’ recalls Roberston. ‘The whole folkie thing was still very questionable to us—it wasn’t the train we came in on. … He’d come up with something like ‘Royal Canal,’ and you’d say, ‘This is so beautiful! The expression!’ … He remembered too much, remembered too many songs too well. He’d come over to Big Pink, or wherever we were, and pull out some old song—and he’d prepped for this. He’d practiced this, and then come out here, to show us.’ Songs recorded at the early sessions included material written or made popular by Johnny Cash, Ian & Sylvia, John Lee Hooker, Hank Williams, and Eric Von Schmidt, as well as traditional songs and standards. Linking all the recordings, both new material and old, is the way in which Dylan re-engaged with traditional American music.
Biographer Barney Hoskyns observed that both the seclusion of Woodstock and the discipline and sense of tradition in the Hawks’ musicianship were just what Dylan needed after the ‘globe-trotting psychosis’ of the 1965–66 tour. Dylan began to write and record new material at the sessions. According to Hudson, ‘We were doing seven, eight, ten, sometimes fifteen songs a day. Some were old ballads and traditional songs … but others Bob would make up as he went along. … We’d play the melody, he’d sing a few words he’d written, and then make up some more, or else just mouth sounds or even syllables as he went along. It’s a pretty good way to write songs.’ Danko told Dylan biographer Howard Sounes, ‘Bob and Robbie, they would come by every day, five to seven days a week, for seven to eight months.’ Hudson added, ‘It amazed me, Bob’s writing ability. How he would come in, sit down at the typewriter, and write a song. And what was amazing was that almost every one of those songs was funny.’
Dylan recorded around thirty new compositions with the Hawks, including some of the most celebrated songs of his career: ‘I Shall Be Released,’ ‘This Wheel’s on Fire,’ ‘Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn),’ ‘Tears of Rage,’ and ‘You Ain’t Goin’ Nowhere.’ Two of these featured his lyrics set to music by members of the Band: Danko wrote the music of ‘This Wheel’s on Fire’; Manuel, who composed ‘Tears of Rage,’ described how Dylan ‘came down to the basement with a piece of typewritten paper … and he just said, ‘Have you got any music for this?’ … I had a couple of musical movements that fit … so I just elaborated a bit, because I wasn’t sure what the lyrics meant. I couldn’t run upstairs and say, ‘What’s this mean, Bob: ‘Now the heart is filled with gold as if it was a purse?”
One of the qualities of ‘The Basement Tape’s that sets it apart from contemporaneous works is its simple, down-to-earth sound. The songs were recorded in mid-1967, the ‘Summer of Love’ that produced the Beatles’ ‘Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band,’ their most technically elaborate album. In a 1978 interview, Dylan reflected on the period: ‘I didn’t know how to record the way other people were recording, and I didn’t want to. The Beatles had just released Sgt. Pepper which I didn’t like at all. I thought that was a very indulgent album, though the songs on it were real good. I didn’t think all that production was necessary.’ Of the sound and atmosphere of the basement recordings, Barney Hoskyns wrote that ‘Big Pink itself determined the nature of this homemade brew.’ ‘One of the things is that if you played loud in the basement, it was really annoying, because it was a cement-walled room,’ recalled Robertson. ‘So we played in a little huddle: if you couldn’t hear the singing, you were playing too loud.’
Mike Marqusee describes how the basement recordings represented a radical change of direction for Dylan, who turned his back on his reputation for importing avant-garde ideas into popular culture: ‘At the very moment when avant-gardism was sweeping through new cultural corridors, Dylan decided to dismount. The dandified, aggressively modern surface was replaced by a self-consciously unassuming and traditional garb. The giddiness embodied, celebrated, dissected in the songs of the mid-sixties had left him exhausted. He sought safety in a retreat to the countryside that was also a retreat in time, or more precisely, a search for timelessness.’
Dylan had married Sara Lownds in November 1965. By the time the basement sessions started in Big Pink he had two children: Maria (Sara’s daughter from her first marriage) and Jesse Dylan. Anna Dylan was born in July of 1967. Both Heylin and biographer Sid Griffin suggest that recording had to move from Dylan’s home to Big Pink when it became clear that the sessions were getting in the way of family life. Domesticity was the context of ‘The Basement Tapes,’ as Hudson said in ‘The Last Waltz’: ‘Chopping wood and hitting your thumb with a hammer, fixing the tape recorder or the screen door, wandering off into the woods with Hamlet [the dog Dylan shared with the Band] … it was relaxed and low-key, which was something we hadn’t enjoyed since we were children.’ Several Basement Tapes songs, such as ‘Clothes Line Saga’ and ‘Apple Suckling Tree,’ celebrate the domestic aspects of the rural lifestyle.
The intense collaboration between Dylan and the Hawks that produced the basement recordings came to an end in October 1967 when Dylan relocated to Nashville to record a formal studio album, ‘John Wesley Harding,’ with a different crew of accompanying musicians. The same month, drummer Levon Helm rejoined his former bandmates in Woodstock, after he received a phone call from Danko informing him that they were getting ready to record as a group. In his autobiography, Helm recalled how he listened to the recordings the Hawks had made with Dylan, and remembered that he ‘could tell that hanging out with the boys had helped Bob to find a connection with things we were interested in: blues, rockabilly, R&B. They had rubbed off on him a little.’
Dylan referred to commercial pressures behind the basement recordings in a 1969 interview with ‘Rolling Stone’: ‘They weren’t demos for myself, they were demos of the songs. I was being PUSHED again into coming up with some songs. You know how those things go.’ A fourteen-song demo tape was copyrighted and the compositions were registered with Dwarf Music, a publishing company jointly owned by Dylan and Grossman. Acetates and tapes of the songs then circulated among interested recording artists. Peter, Paul, and Mary, managed by Grossman, had the first hit with a basement composition, a cover of ‘Too Much of Nothing.’ Ian & Sylvia, also managed by Grossman, recorded ‘Tears of Rage,’ ‘Quinn the Eskimo,’ and ‘This Wheel’s on Fire.’ Manfred Mann reached number one on the UK pop chart with their recording of ‘The Mighty Quinn.’ ‘This Wheel’s on Fire,’ recorded by Julie Driscoll, Brian Auger, and the Trinity, also charted well. The Hawks, officially renamed the Band, recorded ‘This Wheel’s on Fire,’ ‘I Shall Be Released,’ and ‘Tears of Rage’ for their debut album, ‘Music from Big Pink,’ released in 1968.
As tapes of Dylan’s recordings circulated in the music industry, journalists became aware of their existence. In June 1968, Jann Wenner wrote a front-page ‘Rolling Stone’ story headlined ‘Dylan’s Basement Tape Should Be Released.’ Wenner listened to the fourteen-song demo and reported, ‘There is enough material—most all of it very good—to make an entirely new Bob Dylan album, a record with a distinct style of its own.’ He concluded, ‘Even though Dylan used one of the finest rock and roll bands ever assembled on the ‘Highway 61′ album, here he works with his own band for the first time. Dylan brings that instinctual feel for rock and roll to his voice for the first time. If this were ever to be released it would be a classic.’
Reporting such as this whetted the appetites of Dylan fans. In 1969, the first bootleg appeared in California, entitled ‘Great White Wonder.’ The double album consisted of seven songs from the Woodstock basement sessions, plus some early recordings Dylan had made in Minneapolis in 1961 and one track recorded from ‘The Johnny Cash Show.’ One of those responsible for the bootleg, identified only as Patrick, talked to ‘Rolling Stone’: ‘Dylan is a heavy talent and he’s got all those songs nobody’s ever heard. We thought we’d take it upon ourselves to make this music available.’ The process of bootlegging Dylan’s work would eventually see the illegal release of hundreds of live and studio recordings, and lead the Recording Industry Association of America to describe Dylan as the most bootlegged artist in the history of the music industry.
In 1975, Dylan unexpectedly gave permission for the release of a selection of the basement recordings, perhaps because he and Grossman had resolved their legal dispute over the Dwarf Music copyrights on his songs. Clinton Heylin argues that Dylan was able to consent following the critical and commercial success of his just released album ‘Blood on the Tracks.’ ‘After ‘Blood on the Tracks,’ ‘The Basement Tapes’ no longer had the status of a final reminder of Dylan’s lost genius.’ In 1975, as well, the Band purchased Shangri-La ranch in Malibu, which they transformed into their recording studio. Engineer Rob Fraboni was brought to Shangri-La to clean up the recordings still in the possession of Hudson, the original engineer. Fraboni had worked on Dylan’s ‘Planet Waves’ album, with backing by the Band, and the live Dylan–Band album ‘Before the Flood,’ both released in 1974. Fraboni has described Robertson as the dominant voice in selecting the final tracks for ‘The Basement Tapes’ and reported that Dylan was not in the studio very often.
The stereo recordings made by Hudson were remixed to mono, while Robertson and other members of the Band overdubbed new keyboard, guitar, and drum parts onto some of the 1967 Woodstock recordings. According to Fraboni, four new songs by the Band were also recorded in preparation for the album’s official release, one of which, a cover of Chuck Berry’s ‘Going Back to Memphis,’ did not end up being included. There is disagreement about the recording date of the other three songs: ‘Bessie Smith,’ ‘Ain’t No More Cane,’ and ‘Don’t Ya Tell Henry.’ While Fraboni has recalled that the Band taped them in 1975, the liner notes for the reissued versions of the Band’s own albums state that these songs were recorded between 1967 and 1970. Ultimately, eight of the twenty-four songs on ‘The Basement Tapes’ did not feature Dylan, several of them studio outtakes postdating the sessions at Big Pink. In justifying their inclusion, Robertson explained that he, Hudson, and Dylan did not have access to all the basement recordings: ‘We had access to some of the songs. Some of these things came under the heading of ‘homemade’ which meant a Basement Tape to us.’ Robertson has suggested that the Basement Tapes are, for him, ‘a process, a homemade feel’ and so could include recordings from a wide variety of sources.
The cover photograph for the album was taken by designer and photographer Reid Miles in the basement of a Los Angeles YMCA. It poses Dylan and the Band alongside characters suggested by the songs: a woman in a Mrs. Henry T-shirt, an Eskimo, a circus strongman, and a dwarf. Robertson wears a blue Mao-style suit; Manuel wears a U.S. Air Force uniform. Musicians David Blue and Neil Young are also present in the photo.
The album was released to wide acclaim both commercially and critically. However, some critics have pointed to two issues: the recordings by the Band on their own, and the selection of the Dylan songs. In his book about the basement sessions, Greil Marcus describes the album’s contents as ‘sixteen basement recordings plus eight Band demos.’ Critic Michael Gray writes of the album, ‘The interspersed tracks by the Band alone merely disrupt the unity of Dylan material, much more of which should have been included. Key songs missing here include ‘I Shall Be Released’ and ‘The Mighty Quinn.” Heylin similarly argues that compiler Robbie Robertson did Dylan fans ‘a major disservice’ by omitting those two songs as well as ‘I’m Not There’ and ‘Sign On The Cross.’ He writes, ‘The album as released hardly gave a real idea of what they had been doing in Woodstock. Not even the two traditional songs pulled to the master reels—’Young But Daily Growin’ and ‘The Banks Of The Royal Canal’—made the final twenty-four cuts.’
The honesty of the 1975 album was questioned by a reviewer of the remastered version of the Band’s ‘Music From Big Pink,’ issued in 2000. Dave Hopkins noted that ‘Katie’s Been Gone,’ which appears as a bonus track on the Big Pink reissue, is the same recording that appeared on ‘The Basement Tapes,’ but now ‘in stereo and with improved sound quality beyond what the remastering process alone would provide.’ Hopkins declared, ‘The cat’s out of the bag: ‘Katie’ and the other Band-only tracks on ‘The Basement Tapes’ must have been intentionally muddied in the studio in 1975 so that they would fit better alongside the Dylan material recorded in the basement with a home reel-to-reel.’ Heylin also takes exception to Robertson’s passing off the Band’s songs as originating from the basement sessions. By including eight Band recordings to Dylan’s sixteen, he says, ‘Robertson sought to imply that the alliance between Dylan and the Band was far more equal than it was: ‘Hey, we were writing all these songs, doing our own thing, oh and Bob would sometimes come around and we’d swap a few tunes.” Heylin asserts that ‘though revealing in their own right, the Band tracks only pollute the official set and reduce its stature.’
Barney Hoskyns describes ‘Heylin’s objections [as] the academic ones of a touchy Dylanologist: ‘The Basement Tapes’ still contained some of the greatest music either Dylan or the Band ever recorded.’ Sid Griffin similarly defends the inclusion of the Band’s songs: ”Ain’t No More Cane’ may be included under false pretenses, but it is stirring stuff. … And while a Dylan fan might understandably grumble that he wanted to hear another Bob song, a fan equally versed and interested more generally in late 20th century American music would only smile and thank the Good Lord for the gift of this song.’ Of the Band’s version of ‘Don’t Ya Tell Henry,’ he writes, ‘True, the argument could be made that Robertson was way outside his brief in including this on the two-LP set, as this wasn’t from Woodstock or ’67, and has no Dylan on it. … But it is a song from the Basement Tapes era and it swings like a randy sailor on shore leave in a bisexual bar. So give Robbie a break.’
By 1975, Dylan showed scant interest in the discographical minutiae of the recordings. Interviewed on the radio by Mary Travers, he recalled, ‘We were all up there sorta drying out … making music and watching time go by. So, in the meantime, we made this record. Actually, it wasn’t a record, it was just songs which we’d come to this basement and recorded. Out in the woods…’ Heylin has commented that Dylan seemed to ‘dismiss the work as unfinished therapy.’
Although ‘The Basement Tapes’ reached the public in an unorthodox manner, officially released eight years after the songs were recorded, critics have assigned them an important place in Dylan’s development. Michael Gray writes, ‘The core Dylan songs from these sessions actually do form a clear link between … two utterly different albums. They evince the same highly serious, precarious quest for a personal and universal salvation which marked out the ‘John Wesley Harding’ collection—yet they are soaked in the same blocked confusion and turmoil as ‘Blonde On Blonde.’ ‘Tears Of Rage,’ for example, is an exact halfway house between, say, ‘One of Us Must Know (Sooner or Later)’ and ‘I Dreamed I Saw St. Augustine.”
Singer-songwriter David Gray commented that the great achievement of ‘The Basement Tapes’ is that Dylan found a way out of the anguish and verbal complexity that had characterized his mid-sixties albums such as ‘Blonde on Blonde’: ‘It’s the sound of Dylan letting his guard down. ‘Clothes Line Saga’ and all those ridiculous songs, he’s obviously just making it all up, they were having such a great time. The sound of the Band is so antiquated like something out of the Gold Rush and Dylan fits in because he’s this storyteller with an ancient heart. At the time everything he did was so scrutinized, yet somehow he liberated himself from all that and enjoyed making music again. You hear an unselfconscious quality on this record which you don’t ever hear again.’ ‘He mocks his own inertia and impotence,’ writes critic Mike Marqusee, ‘but with a much gentler touch than in ‘Blonde on Blonde.’ In place of that album’s strangled urgency, Dylan adopts a laconic humor, a deadpan tone that speaks of resignation and self-preservation in the face of absurdity and betrayal.’
Robert Shelton has argued that the album revolves around two sets of themes. One group of songs is ‘tinctured with the search for salvation’: ‘I Shall Be Released’ (on the demo, but not on the album), ‘Too Much of Nothing,’ ‘Nothing Was Delivered,’ ‘This Wheel’s On Fire,’ ‘Tears of Rage,’ and ‘Goin’ To Acapulco.’ ”Nothing’ and ‘nowhere’ perplex and nag’ in these songs, he writes. ‘The ‘nothing’ echoes the artist’s dilemma: death versus life, vacuum versus harvest, isolation versus people, silence versus sound, the void versus the life-impulse.’ A second group, comprising ‘songs of joy, signaling some form of deliverance,’ includes most of the remaining songs in the collection.
In his sleeve notes for the 1975 release of ‘The Basement Tapes,’ Greil Marcus wrote, ‘What was taking place as Dylan and the Band fiddled with the tunes, was less a style than a spirit—a spirit that had to do with a delight in friendship and invention.’ He compared the songs to fabled works of American music: ‘The Basement tapes are a testing and a discovery of roots and memory … they are no more likely to fade than Elvis Presley’s ‘Mystery Train’ or Robert Johnson’s ‘Love In Vain.”
In 1997, after listening to more than 100 basement recordings issued on various bootlegs, Marcus extended these insights into a book-length study, ‘Invisible Republic’ (reissued in 2001 under the title ‘The Old, Weird America’). In it, he quotes Robertson’s memory of the recording: ‘[Dylan] would pull these songs out of nowhere. We didn’t know if he wrote them or if he remembered them. When he sang them, you couldn’t tell.’ Marcus calls the songs ‘palavers with a community of ghosts. … These ghosts were not abstractions. As native sons and daughters they were a community. And they were once gathered in a single place: on the ‘Anthology of American Folk Music.’ A collection of blues and country music recorded in the 1920s and 1930s, the Anthology—compiled by Harry Smith and originally released by Folkways Records in 1952—was a major influence on the folk music revival of the 1950s and the 1960s. Marcus suggests that Dylan’s Basement Tapes shared with Smith’s Anthology a sense of alchemy, ‘and in the alchemy is an undiscovered country.’
While removed from the public’s gaze, Dylan and the Band made music very different from the recordings of other major artists. Andy Gill writes, ‘Musically, the songs were completely at odds with what was going on in the rest of the pop world, which during the long hot summer of 1967 was celebrating the birth of the hippie movement with a gaudy explosion of ‘psychedelic’ music—mostly facile paeans to universal love draped in interminable guitar solos.’ Patrick Humphries itemizes the ways in which Dylan’s songs dissented from the dominant ethos of rock culture: ‘While the rock world vented its spleen on parents and leaders, Dylan was singing privately about parental fidelity. While George Harrison was testifying that life went on within and without you, Dylan was taking his potatoes down to be mashed. While Mick Jagger was 2,000 light years from home, Dylan was strapping himself to a tree with roots.’
This aspect of the basement recordings became obvious when Dylan chose to record his next album, ‘John Wesley Harding,’ in Nashville in late 1967. The songs on that record, according to Howard Sounes, revealed the influence of Dylan’s daily reading of both the Bible and the Hank Williams songbook. And its sound came as a shock to other rock musicians. As producer Bob Johnston recalled, ‘Every artist in the world was in the studio trying to make the biggest-sounding record they possibly could. So what does [Dylan] do? He comes to Nashville and tells me he wants to record with a bass, drum and guitar.’ Dylan summed up the gap: ‘At that time psychedelic rock was overtaking the universe and we were singing these homespun ballads.’
When the Band began work on their debut album, ‘Music from Big Pink,’ in a New York studio in 1968, they employed a recording technique similar to the one they had become familiar with during the Basement Tapes sessions. As Robertson described it, ‘We used the same kind of mike on everything. A bit of an anti-studio approach. And we realized what was comfortable to us was turning wherever we were into a studio. Like the Big Pink technique.’ That technique influenced groups including the Beatles, writes Griffin, who calls their Twickenham ‘Get Back’ sessions in early 1969 an effort to record ‘in the honest, live, no frills, no overdubs, down home way that the Hawks/Band did for the Basement Tapes.’
‘Listening to ‘The Basement Tapes’ now, it seems to be the beginning of what is called Americana or alt.country,’ wrote Billy Bragg. ‘The thing about alt.country which makes it ‘alt’ is that it is not polished. It is not rehearsed or slick. Neither are ‘The Basement Tapes.’ Remember that ‘The Basement Tapes’ holds a certain cultural weight which is timeless—and the best Americana does that as well.’ The songs’ influence has been detected by critics in many subsequent acts. Stuart Bailie wrote, ‘If rock’n’roll is the sound of a party in session, the Basement Tapes were the morning after: bleary, and a bit rueful but dashed with emotional potency. Countless acts—Mercury Rev, Cowboy Junkies, Wilco, The Waterboys—have since tried to get back to that place.’
For Elvis Costello, ‘The Basement Tapes’ ‘sound like they were made in a cardboard box. I think [Dylan] was trying to write songs that sounded like he’d just found them under a stone. As if they sound like real folk songs—because if you go back into the folk tradition, you will find songs as dark and as deep as these.’